Editor’s Note: A version of this story also appeared in The Good, the Bad, and the Elegy, a newsletter from the Daily Yonder focused on the best, and worst, in rural media, entertainment, and culture. Every other Thursday, it features reviews, retrospectives, recommendations, and more. You can join the mailing list at the bottom of this article to receive future editions in your inbox.
I believe movie trailers are a truly special art form. I have spent a lot of time professing my love for trailers as a small sliver of genuine entertainment. They build excitement, start conversations, show off creative editing skills, and allow me to decide which movies deserve my time and money. However, I must admit that recently, my precious movie trailers betrayed me.
When the trailer for “The Sheep Detectives” (2026) played before a movie I was seeing in the theater, I turned to my friend with a massive eye roll. Why did all these stars agree to do this silly film? Sigh… just another cash-grab. They just aren’t making kids’ movies like they did when we were young! After writing off the film as nonsense, I vowed not to see it. However, duty calls, and my duties include reviewing rural media for the Daily Yonder.
Promotional trailer for “The Sheep Detectives” (2026). (Credit: Amazon MGM Studios via YouTube)
So last week, I sat down in a fully packed theater, seats filled with audience members ranging from groups of chattering young kids with their parents to solo adults looking for a light, weeknight film. This crowd was engaged in the movie from its very first moment, when the classic MGM Lion let out a “baaa” instead of its typical roar. As the movie continued, I got to be a part of the best kind of movie theater experience, where a whole crowd moves through a range of emotions all together. We laughed, we gasped, and yes, we cried, at a movie about sheep who are detectives.
My initial reaction to “The Sheep Detectives’” trailer was proven incorrect. What I saw was not profit-driven slop, but a sweet and poignant (albeit silly) movie for all ages.
“The Sheep Detectives,” directed by Kyle Balda, is based on the 2005 novel “Three Bags Full” by Leonie Swann and tells the story of George, a kindly loner shepherd (Hugh Jackman) who loves nothing more in the world than his flock of sheep. He takes great care of them, gives them each a name, and of course, reads them murder mystery stories every night.
So when one day the sheep awake to find George dead, they are well-equipped to solve the murder. The sheep, voiced by a star-studded cast including Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Patrick Stewart, Chris O’Dowd, Bryan Cranston, Bella Ramsey, Brett Goldstein, and Regina Hall, devise a plan using what they know from all the books George had read to them to uncover the truth behind their beloved shepherd’s death. They head into the fictional rural British town of Denbrook to interact with the townspeople who may have had a motive in the murder. (The human cast is equally full of talent, with actors such as Emma Thompson, Hong Chau, Nicholas Braun, Molly Gordon, and more.) As the mystery unfolds, so do powerful lessons on memory, grief, and compassion.
“The Sheep Detectives” is a PG “Knives Out” with a similar whodunnit structure – complete with hints, twists, and a big reveal. Also similar to the “Knives Out” franchise is the colorful cast of characters/suspects. In this film, these are the residents of Denbrook, a town whose rurality is central to the drama of the movie. In typical Hollywood fashion, Denbrook is depicted as a place where all of the residents know each other’s business — and nothing fuels a scandal like small-town gossip. One of the lessons that the sheep learned from their murder mystery education is that the criminal is often an outsider, making them distrustful of anyone new to Denbrook. The sheep, who until now have remained in their pasture, are learning the town dynamics along with the viewer. The movie follows the tropes of small-town mysteries, but is never mean-spirited in its depiction. Denbrook, although fictional, will feel familiar to many, and the film invites viewers to laugh together at the quirks of small-town tension.
But within the cozy small-town mystery is the aspect of the film that many viewers are talking about most: its surprising emotional depth. The sheep are coping with intense grief and have to learn to move forward without the person they love the most. The film treats that loss with an unexpected level of care, leading to genuinely tear-inducing moments alongside comedic ones. Rather than shying away from difficult emotions, the film addresses important lessons for young children (and the rest of us) about some of life’s biggest challenges.
Promotional poster for “The Sheep Detectives” (2026). (Credit: Amazon MGM Studios)
Now, one thing I must make clear is that “The Sheep Detectives” does not hold a candle to my favorites in the heartwarming, talking-animals genre. Undisputed classics like “Paddington” (2014) and “Babe” (1995) will be films I insist my future children watch, and “The Sheep Detectives” likely will not fall into that category. Even though I was pleasantly surprised by the film, it was missing a bit of the clever charm that my absolute favorite children’s movies possess. This weakness was largely due to some of the flat and uninteresting human characters. The human interactions were the moments that I was reminded that I was, in fact, watching a movie for kids, with one-note caricatures of adults who added more annoyance than story elevation.
But overall, I am thrilled that this movie got a theatrical release, especially for young children who might get their first theater experience with “The Sheep Detectives.” It’s the kind of fun, warm experience that can create a lasting positive association with watching stories unfold alongside a room full of people.
And movie trailers, don’t worry, I will always love you. I just have to remind myself and other theater-goers to keep an open mind, lest you get (pardon the pun)… fleeced.
This article first appeared in The Good, the Bad, and the Elegy, an email newsletter from the Daily Yonder focused on the best, and worst, in rural media, entertainment, and culture. Every other Thursday, it features reviews, recommendations, retrospectives, and more. Join the mailing list today to have future editions delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign up
The post Don’t Underestimate “The Sheep Detectives” appeared first on The Daily Yonder.
